One of the New York Public Library's Best New Comics for Adults!
"Intensively researched and beautifully rendered... the graphic novelist Tillie Walden used nearby resources to visualize the true story of seamstresses who shared a home for decades."–Robert Ito, The New York Times
"A rare gem of a book... set against the backdrop of a young country moving through constant, and colossal, transformation."–Tahneer Oksman, NPR Books
"Walden takes what’s known of their remarkable true story, bolstering it with well-researched, tender, believable detail, thus animating their loving 44-year relationship, all against the backdrop of the early years of America itself."–Lucy Scholes, The Financial Times
"Sublime... A persuasive case for the greatness of the graphic novel form."–Emily Donaldson, The Globe & Mail
"It’s hard to imagine a cartoonist more brilliantly suited than Walden to illuminate this slice of queer history."—Publishers Weekly Starred Review
"A timeless story of marriage, well-grounded in queer history. An absolute triumph." —Kirkus Starred Review
“In Charity and Sylvia, the preternaturally gifted Tillie Walden surpasses herself. She relates this true story of two women living as a couple in early 19th century Vermont with a pitch-perfect blend of modern sensibility and richly textured archival detail. Her irrepressible drawings are crowded with large families in small candlelit houses, the tackle and trim of daily chores, moody landscapes, and shifting weather. As the scenes of life in a New England village unspool, time seems to slow and lengthen to a pre-industrial pace, with plenty of room for contemplation. Charity and Sylvia ply their needles with a patience and dedication that seem almost inconceivable to us today, but Walden’s unstinting pen gives them a run for their money.” —Alison Bechdel, Fun Home
“A fascinating and moving story that’s told perfectly with compassion, grace, and a beautiful drawing style.” —Chester Brown, Paying For It
“Charity and Sylvia is a staggering achievement: a lesbian love story that both moves and enlightens us. Tillie Walden has vividly brought to life the passion, struggles, and everyday realities of two women who – in the American semi-wilderness – built a life together with hard work, commitment, and joy. Walden's work – like that of Charity and Silvia’s – is a marriage of art and love.” —Michael Bronski, A Queer History of the United States
“A moving historical epic and a story of love, all told in kitchens, bedrooms, sewing parlors. As we ask ourselves how we might survive now, this mostly true love story almost as old as the state, full of what we love about the queer women who lived then, describing how they found their love and how they worked to keep it and each other safe, well, this is not just a book but a rock in a storm, and with answers. Tillie Walden shines as always in portraying the mix of the little sillinesses, serious moments, the humor and affection that held them amid so much of what tried to tear them apart, but taken together what accumulates in the eye and the heart can only be a masterpiece.” —Alexander Chee, How to Write an Autobigraphical Novel
"One of the most profound and subversive contributions to the genre."—Rob Salkowitz, Forbes
"Charity and Sylvia takes readers into rural Vermont in the early and mid-1800s to tell the story of one of the oldest documented queer relationships in America."—CBC Q
"Through the care and energy of [Walden's] pen, Charity Bryant and Sylvia Drake emerge from these pages with an immediacy and vivaciousness that makes it hard to believe that they lived out their entwined lives almost 200 years ago."—Felix Chau Bradley, Xtra!
"Monumental... A vital glimpse of American history, stunningly, compassionately, and deftly told."—Booklist Starred Review
"Walden foregrounds intimacy over spectacle in this historical biography chronicling the decade-spanning romance between two women who defied the social constraints of early 19th-century New England by living together as an openly gay couple."—Thomas Batten, Library Journal Starred Review
"A revealing portrait of two women and the love that sustained them for decades.”—Suzanne Krohn, Shelf Awareness
"Tillie Walden tells this story with such deftness: slice-of-life vignettes are interspersed with letters, dreams, lists, and mentions of Black and Indigenous history unfolding at the same time.”—Book Riot, Best Books of 2026 — So Far
"Walden’s deeply sensitive storytelling gives their romance the emotional weight and reverence it deserves as a foundational moment in U.S. queer history."—Oliver Sava, The AV Club
"A fascinating history destined for queer studies reading lists the world over."—Emily Rems, The Comics Journal
"A poignant illustration of love in early America."—Rylan Hynes, The Portland Press Herald
"Stitched together from an extensive archive of letters, journals and poetry, Walden’s moving, sepia-toned volume is narrated through both women... as they navigate questions of identity, community and faith."—Nyala Ali, Winnipeg Free Press
"I will truly read anything penned by cartoonist Tillie Walden."—Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya, Autostraddle
"Charity & Sylvia illuminates a 200-year-old queer love story.”—Frances Cannon, Seven Days
"A truly moving graphic biography of two real women."—North Country Public Radio
“Let the deeply engrossing history of these pious—yet stubbornly rebellious—lovers give you a break from hot girl summer and plunge you into Intimate Lesbian Winter.”—Suzette Smith, The Portland Mercury
"A must-have for comics fans, history lovers, and those looking to create robust, physical libraries of stunningly rendered LGBTQIA+ media.”—Samantha Puc, The Comics Beat
"An astounding tribute to a 200-year-old lesbian romance and the early beginnings of the LGBTQ+ movement, as well as a fitting, immensely creative contribution to queer history.”—The Bay Area Reporter