Graphic Novel Review: A WITCH’S GUIDE TO BURNING and comics poetry
Comics Beat | Sean Dillon | June 27, 2024
Comics Beat reviews A Witch’s Guide to Burning
One of my major interests within the comics format is the usage of poetry therein. Poetry, contrary to popular belief, is among the trickier forms of writing. It is not simply writing in a specific meter with a rhyme scheme and a few colorful phrases. Poetry requires an understanding of meaning. The effect of a word or phrase both in context and in isolation. It is quite possibly the most underrated visual medium because it is not typically seen as a visual medium.
Take, for example, the previous paragraph. As written, it has the effect of a typical work of prose writing wherein the goal is exposition regarding my own personal relationship with the medium. As such, the words are contextualized within the nature of prose and are read in a specific way that emphasizes specific elements because of where they are placed within the paragraph. But suppose I wrote the paragraph thusly:
One of my major interests within
the comics format is
the usage of poetry
therein.
Poetry,
contrary to popular belief,
is among the trickier forms of writing.
It is not simply writing
in a specific meter
with a rhyme scheme
and a few colorful phrases.
Poetry
requires an understanding
of meaning.
The effect of a word
or phrase
both in context
and in
isolation.
It is quite possibly the most underrated visual medium
because it is not typically seen as
a visual medium.
As you can see, each sentence is a different stanza. Moreover, specific words and phrases take on new emphasis because of their removal from the paragraph’s context. The brain registers an emphasis on “or phrase” as separate from the rest of the sentence because of it being in a completely different line. Patterns emerge from the structuring of sentences unnoticed in traditional prose such as “It is not simply writing/in a specific meter/with a rhyme scheme/and a few colorful phrases.”
And yet, this remains a quite simplistic poetic form. While the poem completely utilizes enjambment, it does so solely within the context of each stanza. Imagine, for example, if the word “isolation” was in its own stanza rather than acting as the final line of a stanza. For that matter, the poem relies on traditional grammar techniques such as capitalization and punctuation. How would the poem read with those elements excised? Or, for that matter, if specific words and phrases were bolded, written in a different color, or excised completely.
I bring this up because this is where my mind immediately went to the second I opened A Witch’s Guide to Burning. While on the surface appearing to be more in line with the illustrated prose of Carrol’s Alice in Wonderland or Jolley’s Unbecoming, Aminder Dhaliwal’s follow up the excellent Cyclopedia Exotica utilizes several poetic devices, including several exclusive to the comics medium.
The most obvious of these comes in the very first page: erasure.
Erasure is a form of poetry wherein one takes an already existing text (whether it be invented by the poet or by another author) and removing elements of the text. The original text from which the erasure has been done is still present, but hidden, be it by fire, ink, or damage. It is known that there were once words here with meanings and implications of their own. But they have been deliberately taken from us. In this case, by fire.
Check out the rest of the review here!
Take, for example, the previous paragraph. As written, it has the effect of a typical work of prose writing wherein the goal is exposition regarding my own personal relationship with the medium. As such, the words are contextualized within the nature of prose and are read in a specific way that emphasizes specific elements because of where they are placed within the paragraph. But suppose I wrote the paragraph thusly:
One of my major interests within
the comics format is
the usage of poetry
therein.
Poetry,
contrary to popular belief,
is among the trickier forms of writing.
It is not simply writing
in a specific meter
with a rhyme scheme
and a few colorful phrases.
Poetry
requires an understanding
of meaning.
The effect of a word
or phrase
both in context
and in
isolation.
It is quite possibly the most underrated visual medium
because it is not typically seen as
a visual medium.
As you can see, each sentence is a different stanza. Moreover, specific words and phrases take on new emphasis because of their removal from the paragraph’s context. The brain registers an emphasis on “or phrase” as separate from the rest of the sentence because of it being in a completely different line. Patterns emerge from the structuring of sentences unnoticed in traditional prose such as “It is not simply writing/in a specific meter/with a rhyme scheme/and a few colorful phrases.”
And yet, this remains a quite simplistic poetic form. While the poem completely utilizes enjambment, it does so solely within the context of each stanza. Imagine, for example, if the word “isolation” was in its own stanza rather than acting as the final line of a stanza. For that matter, the poem relies on traditional grammar techniques such as capitalization and punctuation. How would the poem read with those elements excised? Or, for that matter, if specific words and phrases were bolded, written in a different color, or excised completely.
I bring this up because this is where my mind immediately went to the second I opened A Witch’s Guide to Burning. While on the surface appearing to be more in line with the illustrated prose of Carrol’s Alice in Wonderland or Jolley’s Unbecoming, Aminder Dhaliwal’s follow up the excellent Cyclopedia Exotica utilizes several poetic devices, including several exclusive to the comics medium.
The most obvious of these comes in the very first page: erasure.
Erasure is a form of poetry wherein one takes an already existing text (whether it be invented by the poet or by another author) and removing elements of the text. The original text from which the erasure has been done is still present, but hidden, be it by fire, ink, or damage. It is known that there were once words here with meanings and implications of their own. But they have been deliberately taken from us. In this case, by fire.
Check out the rest of the review here!